DISCUSSIONE FINALE:
Recent evidence has illustrated a role for prostaglandins in regulating hair growth. For example, the PGF2a analog latanoprost is Food and Drug Administration (FDA)–approved and routinely used clinically to enhance hair growth of human eyelashes (15). PGE2 has been pro- posed to protect from radiation-induced hair loss in mice (29), and both PGE2 and PGF2a have been shown to enhance hair growth in mice (20). Our studies show that prostaglandins are dysregulated in AGA, the most common type of hair loss in men. Specifically, PGD2 inhibits hair growth and thus represents a negative counterbalance to the pos- itive effects on hair growth shown for PGE2 and PGF2a.
There is precedence for the opposing functions of individual pros- taglandins that are downstream from the PTGS enzymes. For exam- ple, in the lung, PGE2 causes relaxation, whereas PGD2 causes contraction of bronchial muscle tone (16). Our results suggest that in mouse and human skin, a balance between PGE2 and PGD2 controls hair growth. This model predicts then that efforts to reverse alopecia should optimally focus on both enhancing PGE2 and inhibiting PGD2 signaling. This model also explains why agents such as aspirin, which inhibit upstream prostaglandin synthesis enzymes (PTGS1 and PTGS2), have minimal effects on hair growth because of likely equally decreased production of PGE2 and PGD2.
Given our current report that PGD2 inhibits hair growth, prosta- glandins represent an underappreciated network for controlling the rate of hair lengthening. Evidence to support the PGD2 pathway’s di- rect induction of the apoptotic catagen stage includes the temporal expression of Ptgds with catagen onset, in vitro studies of 15-dPGJ2 showing inhibition of hair growth, and the Ptgs2-overexpressing mouse model, which develops alopecia (23). These results are consistent with the notion that PTGDS elevation in balding scalp leads to increased levels of PGD2 and 15-dPGJ2, which then promote the onset of catagen and decrease hair lengthening, leading to the in- crease in telogen follicles and miniaturization of the hair follicle characteristic of AGA. PGD2 may also cause sebaceous hyperplasia seen in AGA.
Although we did not elicit premature catagen in mice treated topi- cally with PGD2, we observed a negative effect on hair growth (Fig. 6). This could be explained because of inappropriate prostaglandin delivery, frequency, or concentration. Other explanations include potential cofac- tors that are required with PGD2 to more directly affect hair cycling. Nevertheless, our results do suggest that prostaglandins directly modu- late speed of hair growth during anagen. Current explanations of the differences in hair length by species focus mostly on duration of hair follicle cycling rather than accompanying potential differences in hair- lengthening rates during anagen (4). Our results suggest that greater attention should be paid to the possibility that prostaglandins modulate hair growth speed and that compounds increasing hair growth speed may benefit patients with AGA.
Intriguingly, Ptgds is a highly testosterone-responsive transcript (30, 31), which further suggests its importance in AGA. PGD2 is thought to play a central role in male gonadal sex determination (32) and is highly expressed in male genitalia (32, 33). Similarly, Ptgds expression in the heart is regulated by estrogen (34). Estrogen leads to increases in 15-dPGJ2 levels in the uropygial gland (35). Recent evidence also suggests that pros- taglandins induce virilization of the mouse brain through estrogen (36). Given the androgens are aromatized into estrogens, these results may be relevant to hair growth and alopecia in both men and women. Thus, these or similar pathways might be conserved in the skin and suggest that sex hormone regulation of Ptgds may contribute to the pathogenesis of AGA.
Additional evidence that prostaglandins control hair follicle cycling and can be used therapeutically to treat AGA arises from findings on the possible mechanism of the AGA drug minoxidil. Although min- oxidil alters potassium channel kinetics (7), it is also known to increase production of PGE2 (37). Given the decreased amount of PGE2 present in bald scalp versus haired scalp (Fig. 2E), minoxidil may normalize PGE2 levels. Future studies should address whether minoxidil can con- comitantly decrease PGD2 levels and thus normalize multiple prosta- glandin species as a mechanism to improve AGA.
The lower absolute amount of 15-dPGJ2 compared to PGE2 and PGD2 is particularly relevant; although this eicosanoid has been hy- pothesized to be a natural ligand for the nuclear hormone transcription factor peroxisome proliferator–activated receptor g (PPARg), the measured concentration of 15-dPGJ2 is often lower than the binding constant for PPARg (17). Thus, although it is attractive to speculate that the sebaceous gland hypertrophy and elevated levels of 15-dPGJ2 ob- served in both human AGA and mouse K14-Ptgds model might be re- lated, the causal connection is unclear. Despite this, a growing literature correlates elevated 15-dPGJ2 levels with sebaceous hyperplasia, such as in acne (38). Given the common requirement of circulating sex hor- mones and common histology of sebaceous hyperplasia, acne and AGA may have overlapping pathogeneses.
Another report has linked altered lipid metabolism and alopecia (39). In a distinct type of human alopecia called lichen planopilaris, expression of PPARg is decreased with accompanying altered lipid metabolism. These were discovered through an approach similar to ours using micro- array analysis of affected and unaffected scalp. The most up-regulated transcript from affected subjects, cytochrome P450 family 1 member A1 (CYP1A1), was up-regulated 1020-fold. The authors hypothesized that a xenobiotic, such as dioxin, might up-regulate CYP1A1 expression and trigger lichen planopilaris. However, cytochrome P450s also have roles in eicosanoid biology, and they may alter prostaglandin metabolism (40). Thus, altered prostaglandin metabolism might contribute to more than one type of human alopecia, although additional studies are needed. Our findings should lead directly to new treatments for the most common cause of hair loss in men, AGA. Given its suspected role in allergic diseases, at least 10 antagonists of the GPR44 (DP-2) receptor have been identified (41) and several are in clinical trials (42). The potential for developing these compounds into topical formulations for treating AGA should elicit great interest moving forward. The ques- tion of whether similar changes in PGD2 levels are found in the affected scalp of women with AGA also needs to be addressed. AGA in women may not be androgen-mediated, but if prostaglandins represent a final common pathway, targeting prostaglandins should benefit women with AGA as well.
Our findings also suggest that supplemental PGE2 could be ther- apeutic. By correcting its deficiency and increasing its level in bald scalp, the inhibitory effects of PGD2 may be overcome. Analogs of PGF2a, which are already FDA-approved to promote eyelash growth, should also have similar effects on the scalp and are currently in clin- ical trials for this indication. Once issues of delivery, dosing, and safety are addressed, additional agonists and antagonists of prostaglandin pathways should become available. The K14-Ptgs2 transgenic mouse model, which phenocopies AGA, may assist in screening novel ther- apeutic agents. Ultimately, multiple mechanisms may be responsible for hair loss in AGA. Inhibiting PGD2 may prevent miniaturization and provide benefit to those in the process of balding; however, it is unclear whether men who are already bald will regrow hair.